Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

Chocolate
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Malt Balls

128 reviews
$11.99 USD
1.0 lb
Melty Mints

102 reviews
$14.99 USD
Brad's Sweet & Salty Trail Mix

37 reviews
From $8.99 USD
8.0 oz
Malt Balls Milk Chocolate No Sugar Added

80 reviews
$12.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Raisins

83 reviews
$9.99 USD
12.0 oz
Dark Nonpareils

62 reviews
$9.99 USD
12.0 oz
Dark Chocolate Almonds

71 reviews
$12.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Coconut Haystacks

78 reviews
$10.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Pretzels

50 reviews
$10.99 USD
12.0 oz
Large Dark Nonpareils

66 reviews
$11.99 USD
12.0 oz
Dark Chocolate Pretzels

38 reviews
$10.99 USD
Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Almonds
12.0 oz
Sugar Free (No Sugar Added) Dark Chocolate Almonds

62 reviews
$11.99 USD
12.0 oz
English Toffee Squares

72 reviews
$17.99 USD
Sale
72% Cacao Extra Dark Chocolate Almonds

63 reviews
From $9.99 USD $14.99 USD
Fall in Love
Fall in Love (with this mix) Trail Mix

48 reviews
From $10.99 USD
Mini Dark Chocolate Chips
12.0 oz
Mini Dark Chocolate Chips

46 reviews
$11.99 USD
12.0 oz
Pecan Patties Milk Chocolate

52 reviews
$12.99 USD
12.0 oz
Dark Chocolate Raisins

33 reviews
$10.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Peanuts

32 reviews
$9.99 USD
Goldenberg's Dark Chocolate Peanut Chews

36 reviews
From $8.99 USD
12.0 oz
Mint Lentils

50 reviews
$12.99 USD
Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Raisin
12.0 oz
Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Raisins (no sugar added)

49 reviews
$9.99 USD
8.0 oz
Malt Balls Dark Chocolate No Sugar Added

52 reviews
$12.99 USD
Dark Chocolate Covered Walnut
Dark Chocolate Covered Walnuts

49 reviews
From $11.99 USD
Our All American Apple Pie Mix

53 reviews
From $10.99 USD
Espresso Beans Dark Chocolate Covered

41 reviews
From $13.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Almonds

33 reviews
$10.99 USD
12.0 oz
Dark Chocolate Malt Balls

49 reviews
$12.99 USD
5.0 oz
Marshmallow Twists

24 reviews
$4.99 USD
12.0 oz
Milk Chocolate Nonpareils

33 reviews
$10.99 USD
Limoncello Almonds
Sold Out
1.0 lb
Limoncello (Lemon Creme) Almonds

59 reviews
$13.99 USD
Sold Out
Dark Chocolate Blood Orange Caramels

57 reviews
From $10.99 USD
1.0 lb
White Chocolate Pretzels

31 reviews
$9.99 USD
0.75 lb
Wilbur Buds Dark

37 reviews
$19.99 USD
Caryn's Craving
Caryn's Craving

18 reviews
From $8.99 USD
Sugar Free Milk Chocolate Raisins
12.0 oz
Sugar Free Milk Chocolate Raisins (no sugar added)

32 reviews
$14.99 USD
199 results